The Sony NEX 5N User Report

The Sony NEX 5N is a great camera.  If you’re the type who reads camera reviews and user reports and immediately scrolls to the end to find out the bottom line, then there… I just gave you the bottom line.  It’s a great camera.  And I didn’t think it would be.

Now, the longer version…

Anytime anybody messes with the standard, defies convention, tries to reinvent all in the name of innovation, then they’re taking a massive risk.  If you figure it out as Apple did with the iPod, then they put on the cover of Newsweek and MBA students study you.  Fail and you become the butt of every joke and MBA students do study, but not for the reason you’d prefer.  Well, for traditionalists (like me), messing with tried and true conventions seems like extra risky business.  One of the reasons I love the Fujifilm X100 is that it brings me back to aperture dials and the ability to adjust key settings such as exposure compensation via reassuring and unabashedly physical dials and buttons.  No menu surfing here.  On DSLRs, the ubiquitous mode dial allows all but the most photographically inexperienced to pick up the beast and start shooting.  “A” means Aperture Priority.  A little picture of a person’s head means portrait mode, if you stoop so low as to shoot with a camera with scene modes.  Conventions.  They work… so why tinker?

Sony tinkered…

Simply looking at the NEX 5N, which essentially follows the form established by the earlier NEX 3 and NEX 5, you’ll see that Sony does it all quite differently.  Push a button to jump into a customizable interface and you’ll see that mode dial alright, but it will show up on the big and bouncy (i.e., swivel up and down) LCD screen.  Turn the multipurpose control wheel and you see that “A”.  Aperture Priority.  Ah… OK, there it is.

Presumably, this is all done in the name of allowing for a tiny body.  You couldn’t possibly cram all the usual suspect dials and buttons on a body this small.  So, Sony went back to the drawing board.

I looked at the camera initially and thought, “Uhm… I don’t think so.”  But, what I found was a very highly customizable interface.  The top of two back facing buttons is set to menu… good.  The right most position on the depressible control wheel can be set to… well, lots of things.  I set it to the DRO function so that I could turn on the dynamic range optimizer function, which helps bring up bright spots and tone down dark spots, providing more usable detail.  There also is the very usable Auto HDR mode (which you can set to +/- 2EV or even more… nice Sony!) which is found within the DRO menu.  The bottom button, I declared would be where I set ISO, though in reality, the very nice high ISO capabilities (see below) allowed for quite a bit of ISO range flexing, and so I eventually abandoned this setting in favor or more autofocus control.

The 5N deploys the highly regarded, though constantly being updated, Sony 16mp processor.  This may or not be identical to the one used in APS-C leading Nikon D7000 and Pentax K-5 bodies, but I can tell you that it’s just as nice.  It shows supreme dynamic range and a great ability to dial up ISO in darker conditions.

The above photo is an example of Auto HDR (+/- 2 EV), nicely stitched in camera… and all made the more practical by virtue of the speedy 10 frames per second.  Handheld HDR is very possible here (in all but the most light starved of scenarios).

The photo below (quite the appetizer, with a wonderful sampler of salamis) was shot at ISO 6400.  Sure, there’s noise, but this is just not bad.  I’ve been recently shooting with my original KM 5D DSLR and this noise level is about what we used to get at 800.  Now that’s progress.

Like the X100, the NEX also includes an auto Panorama mode.  It works great, though of course if there’s much movement, you’ll get some funky stitching effects.  There’s also a 3D pano mode which requires some specialized connections and TV hardware so I couldn’t be bothered.  I’m not one for 3D anyways.

I found the AF performance to be hearty and reliable.  After shooting with the X100 for so long, I forgot that swift AF on non-DSLRs could be this good.  Overall performance, including start-up times and that wonderful frame rate, are all fantastic.

What’s not fantastic?  The NEX system.  Not yet anyways.  At this point, there’s the 16/2.8 which isn’t quite wide enough to be my go-to wide solution… nor long enough to be a good street lens.  It’s a tweener and not such a great one at that.  All of my shots from this lens required a good dose of contrast boost afterwards.  In short, it’s rather flat.  The kit 18-55 is pretty adequate… actually it’s more that that.  It’s capable.  There’s also an 18-200 which looks like a giant on this diminutive body.  I didn’t have a chance to test it, but just the appearance of it made me wonder about the whole point of this mirrorless thing.  It’s about being smaller and lighter, right?

Sony has announced more lenses, including a 50/1.8, a 30 macro and a moderate tele-zoom.  There’s also an expensive Zeiss 24 that’s coming by the end of the year.  Now that’s a focal length I’d love to have as it would give you a 36mm equivalent… much like the X100’s 35mm.  I want it, but I won’t justify spending the $1,000 they’re asking for it.

At this point, the m4/3 system has it all over the NEX.  The lens options are much better.  I hope Sony figures out how to fill the pipeline with more lenses, including a fast zoom and more primes… which don’t cost a grand each.

The 5N takes an add on $350 electronic VF which is every bit as nice as the Olympus VF2, which I’ve raved about here.  I tend toward being more comfortable using a VF than a back screen, but I became accustomed to tiling the LCD up and using the small camera in a top down, shoot from the hip posture.  It worked well for me and I didn’t feel as though the VF was a necessity.  The camera ships with a screw in pop up flash which while on the weaker side, actually works quite well.  I don’t like that you have to choose whether to use the VF or the flash in the socket.  I’d like to use both, thank you.

Where the NEX system tops the smaller sensor equipped m4/3 cameras is in dynamic range and high ISO capabilities.  I’ve played around with the m4/3 cameras quite a bit and I’m a fan.  But here, the NEX wins.  This is made all the more interesting by the fact that Nikon just announced their “1” series of cameras which possess a sensor even smaller than m4/3!  I’m sure they don’t want to cannibalize their APS-C line-up, but this move seems rather odd.  At least they’ve put a stake in the mirrorless game, leaving Canon as the only major player not yet at the party.  I don’t expect that will last for very long.

It’s worth noting also that a “clicking” problem has been identified during video capture.  Reportedly, if you move/shake the camera quickly during video shooting, you’ll pick up a noise from the mic that sounds like clicking.  I don’t tend to shake  a camera in that fashion, so I’m not too worried about it, though it might suggest something’s loose inside or a level ball that’s rolling around too close to the mic.  Sony has announced a fix that requires contacting customer service.  I’m impressed that Sony recognized and publicly acknowledged the problem so quickly.  Nikon has had metering issues and Pentax had a sensor stain snafu and both were MIA on the topic, leaving customers, particularly early adopters, out on the lurch.  Good to see Sony taking a different approach.

There’s a Sony NEX 7 coming in November that will possess a 24mp sensor, an in-built electronic VF and a modified “try-navi” interface that provides a couple of extra dials on top for modifying things like aperture and EV.  Tri-navi is highly configurable.  We’ll test the NEX 7 as we get closer to launch.

Ultimately, I found the shooting experience and image quality to be quite strong and Sony has offered a very compelling APS-C mirrorless option.  If they can fill out the system with more and better lenses, I’m sure this is going to be the system to beat.

Finally, you may have seen that 2 Guys Photo is now being sponsored by B&H Photo – see here.  Please consider clicking through one of our links to B&H.  We’ll get a small financial boost and you won’t pay any more.  That will help us expand the site and offer even more content.

Sony NEX 5N body here.

Sony NEX 5N with kit lens here.

Thanks!

Posted by Rey

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Gear & accessories, Images and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

20 Responses to The Sony NEX 5N User Report

  1. I was up early, eager to read your review today! Sounds like an awesome camera. I am going to do some serious thinking about this Sony NEX5N…I need something I can enjoy shooting with when I travel that is not so heavy like my 7D. Great timing to read this..thanks for the heads up on the article! Have a great week!

    • Rey says:

      Thanks, Hillary – please let us know what you decide. The 7D is fantastic (though a tad bulky); I think you’ll find the image quality and diminutive size of the NEX (if you go in that direction) to be a nice alternative.

      Rey

  2. tom says:

    >There also is the very usable Auto HDR mode (which you can set to +/- 2EV or even more… nice Sony!) which is found within the DRO menu. <

    i thought that auto bracketing was limited to 0.7EV — are you saying that the auto HDR is not that limited (but the auto is JPEG only, correct?)?

    there have been complaints from users of the NEX5 that getting into and out of auto HDR and panorama mode, as well as going back and forth from autofocus to manual focus, require too many steps and are cumbersome. i'm not sure if this has changed in the NEX5N due to the touch screen and customization options — are you finding the operational navigation to be a problem?

    • Rey says:

      Tom –

      I was talking about the Auto HDR function. You can go up to +/- 2EV in the auto function (yes, only JPG) and even higher. Sadly, the true exposure bracketing is frustratingly limited to +/- 0.7. Many are lobbying Sony to fix this in a firmware upgrade and there are notable and long-time Sony pros (e.g., Michael Reichmann) who are lobbying super hard to get them to at least make this simple firmware change in the NEX 7, which is probably more likely. I suspect/hope that if they do so on the 7, they will then make it backward compatible to the 5N as well. I don’t have a problem with navigation. It all works nicely, but it’s important to choose your customizations wisely. I did assign the right push of the wheel to the DRO/HDR function so without even peering away from the EVF (one of the joys of EVF is the fact that you can toggle menu items without looking away, of course) I move quickly to/from HDR and DRO settings. The pano mode is on the virtual control wheel and I don’t mind diving into menus because when I shoot pano, it’s a more deliberate action anyways.

      Hope this helps.

      Thanks,

      Rey

  3. I can’t believe I came back tonight ( I had to go to work this morning, you know) and B&H was sold out of the camera even though I had it in my ‘shopping cart’ this morning! 😦 I have a feeling it was this great review that you wrote today… I put myself on the mailing list… I would love for you to get the credit if I do get it! Bummer!

    • Rey says:

      Hillary – glad you found the review useful. Sony is shipping a steady stream of of 5Ns to stores, so it won’t be out of stock at B&H for long. I believe they have silver ones in stock now as a matter of fact.

      Thanks,

      Rey

      • Got an email from them tonight that they are back in stock. I took the plunge and did it through your link to make sure you get the credit for my purchase. Yikes, I can’t believe I did it, but sounds like the camera I need for our trip to Europe in November. I have to travel light, but need a good camera. I’ll have to let you know! Thanks for all your wondeful posts! Hillary

        • Rey says:

          Hillary – congrats! And thank you for using our link. We really appreciate that very much.

          Best of luck with the camera. Would you be so kind as to let us know what you think? And please send us some of your best Europe shots… perhaps we’ll post on the site if you’re game.

          Thanks,

          Rey

          • I would love to share some with you… we don’t leave until Nov 4th until just after Thanksgiving.. I’m really excited to try out the new camera for the trip so I hope I will have time to play with it before we leave. I will be in touch when we get back. Thank you for asking me. I am not a terribly technical person, but since a picture says …a thousand words, I guess we’ll have to let the photos tell their story as to whether I learn how to use the camera! Thank you so much! Hillary

          • Rey says:

            Hillary – have a great trip. We’re interested to hear what you think of the 5N… and please do send us a few photos to post!

            Thanks,

            Rey

  4. tom says:

    yes that is helpful, thanks. it sounds like the programmable button makes a lot of difference.

    is the HDR JPG option hi-res or lo-res (i’m not sure what that would be in Sony talk, e.g. fine or extra fine or whatever)?

    do you find the accessory modes such as auto HDR, twilight mode, DRO, and pano useful enough to be considered “game changers” when comparing the 5N to other systems such a micro 4/3?

    • Rey says:

      Tom –

      High res (fine) jpeg. I would say that “game changers” is a bit stronger than I’d apply. They are very useful and I’m glad to have them. Increasingly, other manufacturers are adding them as well (X100 has the sweep pano, Nikon D5100 has the auto HDR, as do the Pentax cameras, etc.). Sony’s implementation is pretty strong. If they would only allow better auto bracketing (+/- more than the measly 0.7 EV) then I’d say that their deployment of such features is strongest I’ve experienced. Micro 4/3 has the art filters (Olympus) which is pretty nice, but they don’t have auto HDR or Pano and so they’re lagging.

      Thanks,

      Rey

  5. Rey – I had to come back and let you know that I gave the camera it’s first trial run today at our local Scott Kelby Worldwide Photowalk in Doylestown, PA… I didn’t take a lot of photos, but only took the SONY 5N with me so I was forced to use it..no doubt there is a learning curve, but I am in LOVE!!! This camera is amazing! I sort of played by ear with it today and really enjoyed discovering its capabilities… I did not take the manual with me, but now having worked with it a little I will better understand what I need to know with the manual.. After our walk I looked at only a few of the shots on one of the iPads that was available there for us to see our pictures (We met after the walk at Doylestown’s Apple dealer called Mac Outfitters) and EVERYONE was oohing and awwing at the clarity of the images.. Oh boy…this camera is going to be fun! Thank you so much for your review and information on this camera!!!

    • Rey says:

      Hillary – thanks for the feedback. Glad you’re enjoying the camera. You may have noticed that dpreview.com just gave it their coveted (and quite rare) Gold Award. Further proof that this is a pretty special camera.

      Rey

  6. Ooops, that was me just above (aphotographerfriend) who just posted.. I was logged in on a different account! Love the 5N…thanks!

  7. Pingback: Terry Banet: Safari Photographer | 2 Guys Photo

  8. Pingback: Daily Photo Phix: Red Rock Canyon | 2 Guys Photo

  9. Pingback: Ask 2 Guys Photo: Which Superzoom? | 2 Guys Photo

  10. Pingback: Daily Photo Phix: Dessert Trail | 2 Guys Photo

  11. Pingback: Divergent Paths: Fujifilm vs. Sony | 2 Guys Photo

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s